top of page

"He Shouldn't Be Here"

Writer: Janet Ferone
Janet Ferone
9 minutes ago
5 min read

It started with a Facebook message that came out of the blue from a former student who graduated almost 20 years ago:


I answered, congratulating him and telling him how proud I was of him and he replied:


Then another message inviting me to a post-wedding reception, which I was excited to attend. I met up with the groom’s caseworker, Phil, in the parking lot and after not seeing each other for over 15 years, we picked up where we left off and chatted like long lost friends. The hall was decked out in red and black, and we’d been asked to dress in those colors, too. We got there before things got underway. A tall gentleman approached us and when he said he was the groom’s father, I exclaimed “Helicopter Hannah!” as his dad was a well-known basketball legend, having been a star player when he attended the same school. His face burst into a wide smile, thrilled I knew him as a legend and pointed it out several times throughout the night.


Phil and I sat with a lovely grandma, mom, and daughter on the bride’s side and fell into easy conversation. We were careful not to give too many details about him as a teen, as the man they know now is so different than the teen we knew. The vibe in the room was happy excitement as we waited for the couple to make their entrance, and we weren’t disappointed as they danced their way funkily across the floor. More dances followed including the father-daughter dance to The Stanky Leg, a classic hood favorite in contrast to the elegant suburban surroundings, and I loved every minute.

The time came for Phil and me to greet the happy couple, and we began walking across the dance floor when Phil stopped in his tracks. I looked at him, puzzled, and he said, “We shouldn’t be here. Rob shouldn’t be here. This really is against all odds.” While it sounded like a cliché, Phil was referring to all the other youth who were either killed by gang violence, or in prison, or lost to the streets. The most devastating loss was Antoine. He was Rob’s childhood friend and a former middle school student of mine. He was murdered at 15. Rob himself survived a shooting and still carries the emotional scars.

When we made our way over, Rob hugged us as if he didn’t want to let go. He had us both laughing as he teased me about calling Phil when he got into trouble at school, and teased Phil about the times he had to send him back to lockup, and we reminisced about the often heated meetings in my office. As angry as Rob got with us back then, he knew we had his best interests at heart. Over the years, I’ve heard from many former students that holding them accountable was one of the ways they knew we cared, an expression of love. His mom came over and warmly thanked Phil and me for getting him to where he is today.


Back at our table, Phil continued marveling about Rob overcoming the enormous challenges of community violence and neighborhood strife that directly affected him. He said, “In the face of tremendous adversity, Rob became a varsity basketball player, graduated high school and persevered to lead a fulfilling life as a loving father and husband.”

The evening was magical. Seeing a former student dressed to the nines in his smart tuxedo with a brilliant red brocade vest, surrounded by loving family and friends, with his new wife and their children running and playing happily at this joyous celebration, made all the hard work feel worthwhile.

Rob was one of the students I worked with as director of the YES Alternative Program, a Boston Public Schools program for young people with serious behavioral and emotional challenges. Many were in and out of lockup, gang-involved, struggling with substance use, living with violence both in their communities and often in their own homes, moving between foster homes, group homes and other unstable living situations, and often had already been expelled from other special education settings. I didn’t have a playbook when I began working with them. I relied on instinct, authenticity, high expectations and a willingness to keep showing up.

As I thought about why Rob had reached out after all these years, I remembered something another former student wrote to me:


Sometimes the most important thing an educator can give a young person is the persistent message, delivered over years and often through conflict, that their life is worth fighting for.

I also learned that caring about students was not the same as understanding their lives. And as a white woman working primarily with students of color, I also had a lot to learn. I needed to understand not just what happened in school, but the realities of my students’ lives outside of it: their families, neighborhoods, experiences with racism, violence, poverty and the systems they were navigating. I learned to listen closely to my colleagues of color, to trust what they knew about our students and communities, and to keep questioning my own assumptions. Caring alone could easily slide into white-savior territory if I wasn’t also willing to listen, learn and understand the lives my students were actually living.

I had a realization recently while updating my bio for a course I’m teaching. I changed “support international fellows at Boston University” to “supported” because the fellowship program ended more than a year ago.

Then I thought about the previous week.

As I was driving to take a former fellow visiting from Sarajevo out to dinner, another former fellow from Budapest called, excited to tell me that he had worked as an extra in a film and to remind me how much it had meant to him that I took him to theater performances when he was living in Boston. And for the past six years, I have continued to host a monthly Zoom call for fellows from all program years.

I changed “supported” back to “support.” The program ended. The relationships did not.

That’s been true for many of my former Boston Public Schools students, too. Over the years, I’ve gone to baby showers, sat beside former students at their children’s IEP meetings, and joined many at the Mothers Walk for Peace to honor murdered family members. Decades after graduating, another former student, who now works in Boston Public Schools, wrote on Facebook this week, “I STILL CALL & Reach out for Advice.” She joked that I still jump right back into teacher and admin mode when she calls.

I didn’t want the evening to end. I had joked with Phil beforehand that there was no way I was staying for the entire seven-hour reception, yet Phil and I both stayed until midnight. Thinking back to the tough teenager who so often wore a scowl, I found it hard to leave as I watched his face soften into a joyous smile whenever he caught sight of his wife or one of their kids.

As I posed for one final photo with Rob and his wife, it felt extraordinary to take in the life he had built after surviving so much that could have derailed him. I was grateful to have been part of his life then, and even more grateful to be invited back into it now.



 

 For me, the best parts of this work never really end.

Phil Hindin as worked for the MA Department of Youth Services (DY) for over two decades as a caseworker, manager, and program director. He has been recognized by DYS for his work with young people.


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page